Why CSK Dropped Ruturaj Gaikwad: The Data Behind It
Share this article
Ruturaj Gaikwad is still CSK's captain on the team sheet. He just isn't opening any more. For a franchise that built an entire decade of orange-cap hopes around the Pune right-hander, that sentence is an earthquake — and mid-season IPL 2026 is when the data finally tipped the scale.
Stephen Fleming's call to push Sanju Samson and 18-year-old Ayush Mhatre to the top, and drop Ruturaj to No. 3 (and sometimes lower), isn't a vibes decision. It's a cold read of powerplay strike rate, dot-ball percentage, and match-winning intent. Here's the full case.
The headline number — powerplay strike rate
The cleanest way to understand the demotion is powerplay intent.
- Across IPL 2024 + 2025, Ruturaj's powerplay strike rate sat close to 130 — respectable, but below the modern opener benchmark of 150+
- Sanju Samson's career powerplay strike rate is above 145, and in IPL 2026 specifically it's closer to 160
- Ayush Mhatre's T20 strike rate across domestic cricket + IPL has been around 175
CSK lost four openers to injury or form across 2025, and Fleming publicly said the team needed "more powerplay damage." The numbers back him. Per ESPNcricinfo's IPL statsguru, CSK were among the bottom three teams for powerplay run rate in IPL 2025. A team that plays half its games at Chepauk — where chasing is notoriously tough — cannot afford a slow start.
The dot-ball problem
Ruturaj's second structural issue: dot balls. His dot-ball percentage as an opener has hovered around 42%, which is high for a T20 opener in 2026. Modern openers like Travis Head, Abhishek Sharma and Phil Salt sit closer to 32-35%.
Fleming's analytics team, led by performance analyst M Shrikkanth, reportedly flagged this pattern at the mid-season review. Mhatre's dot-ball rate is around 30% — lower than Ruturaj even in the domestic season — and Samson's strike-rotation against spin is elite. Together they solve the dot-ball leak.
The Samson factor
When CSK signed Sanju Samson in the 2025 mega auction as a wicketkeeper-opener, the plan was always to move him up. The Samson-Gaikwad captaincy split — officially shared between the two, but with Samson taking tactical calls when Dhoni isn't on the field — also reshaped the batting order logic.
- Samson's 115* vs DC in Match 18 was CSK's first win of the season
- He has already crossed 200 runs in the powerplay across 2026 and is tracking toward an Orange Cap-contention year
- Keeping him at No. 4 while Ruturaj opened would have wasted the powerplay overs
The Mhatre-Samson combination also gives CSK a left-right and young-experienced balance that works on every surface — including the seamer-friendly early-season tracks at Chepauk in April.
Where does Ruturaj bat now?
Per multiple match reports and a Cricbuzz post-match presser, Fleming has slotted Ruturaj at No. 3 — with an option to push him to No. 4 when CSK face pace-heavy attacks.
The logic:
- No. 3 allows Ruturaj to still face a lot of balls (he averages close to 38 in T20s) without the powerplay pressure
- He can absorb middle-overs spin — one of his career strengths
- If CSK lose an opener early, Ruturaj naturally comes in with a powerplay-ish role
His 41 off 29 in the Match 22 game vs RCB, batting at 3, suggests the role is starting to click — even if the strike rate is still a work in progress.
The captaincy awkwardness
There's no polite way to say it: dropping the captain from the opening slot is unusual in IPL history. The last comparable case was MS Dhoni himself briefly moving down the order in 2020 as a strategic call.
CSK have managed the optics carefully:
- Ruturaj still leads the toss and sets fields
- Samson is publicly positioned as the "keeper-captain" on-field voice when Dhoni is batting
- Dhoni's return from injury on April 14 also helped stabilize dressing-room hierarchy
If CSK qualify for playoffs, the combination stays. If they miss, expect a bigger structural debate next auction cycle.
What the fantasy players should do
For Dream11 and MyCircle11 managers:
- Treat Samson as a C/VC pick whenever CSK bat first
- Mhatre is the value pick — his ownership is still below 25% in many GLs despite strong form
- Ruturaj at No. 3 has lower ceiling but solid floor — use him in small leagues, not grand leagues
- Dhoni finishing is back in play after April 14 — bump his multiplier slightly
The venue also matters. At Chepauk, Mhatre's upside is higher because of boundary size quirks. At Wankhede or Chinnaswamy, Samson is the safer captain.
What Fleming said (paraphrased)
Per multiple iplt20.com interviews, Fleming has framed the change as "giving Ruturaj the role he is most effective in" rather than a demotion. That's standard franchise-speak, but the tactical substance is real — CSK are trying to solve the powerplay, not punish the captain.
Watch the next 4-5 games. If Samson and Mhatre keep going at strike rates above 150, the combination sticks for the whole season. If either dips, Ruturaj is the first candidate to move back up.
FAQ
Q: Is Ruturaj Gaikwad still CSK captain in IPL 2026?
A: Yes, technically. He still captains CSK on the team sheet with Sanju Samson sharing tactical duties. He has only been dropped from the opening slot, not the captaincy.
Q: Why did CSK drop Ruturaj Gaikwad as opener?
A: Powerplay strike-rate concerns. Ruturaj's powerplay SR sat close to 130 across recent IPL seasons, well below the 150+ benchmark modern openers need. Samson and Mhatre both offer higher powerplay intent.
Q: Where does Ruturaj Gaikwad bat now?
A: Primarily at No. 3, occasionally No. 4 depending on the match-up. Fleming wants him to absorb middle-overs spin and anchor the innings without powerplay pressure.
Q: Who opens for CSK in IPL 2026?
A: Sanju Samson and 18-year-old Ayush Mhatre. The combination debuted in Match 18 vs Delhi Capitals and delivered CSK's first win of the season.
Q: Is Sanju Samson the CSK captain now?
A: Not officially. Ruturaj Gaikwad remains captain, but Samson shares leadership duties — especially when Dhoni isn't on the field. It's a functional co-captaincy arrangement.
Q: Will Ruturaj Gaikwad return to opening later?
A: Possible but unlikely this season. If Samson or Mhatre lose form, Ruturaj is the first candidate to move back up. The current plan is to stick with the new combination through the playoffs.
Keep reading
IPL 2026 Fantasy Tools
Share this article
Rahul Sharma
Expert in: Ipl 2026Rahul Sharma has played district-level cricket in Mumbai for 8 years and has personally tested more than 50 bats, pads, gloves, and helmets across different price ranges. He joined CricJosh to help Indian club cricketers make smarter equipment choices without overpaying. His reviews are based on real match and net session use, not sponsored samples.
Why trust this review: Rahul has used every product in this review across multiple match and net sessions before writing a word. He buys equipment at retail price and accepts no free samples.
Related Articles
