When Dhoni Returns: CSK's XI Options + Samson Partnership
Share this article
MS Dhoni's return to the CSK XI is the question defining Chennai Super Kings' IPL 2026. He's expected back within the next 7-10 days per the injury update we've been tracking. When he walks back in, CSK have a selection problem most teams would kill for — too much talent for 11 slots, four players all deserving starts.
Sanju Samson is keeping. Ayush Mhatre is opening. Shivam Dube is finishing. Where does Dhoni go? Who sits? Here are the permutations head coach Stephen Fleming is weighing.
The 4-player puzzle
The four players who can't all keep-or-play-their-best-role simultaneously:
- MS Dhoni — wicketkeeper-finisher, captain-elect if available
- Sanju Samson — wicketkeeper-batter, currently keeping and scoring freely (115* vs DC in Match 18)
- Ayush Mhatre — opener, U19 World Cup-winning captain
- Shivam Dube — finisher / sixth-bowler, Impact Player candidate
Only one can be designated wicketkeeper. Only two can open. Only one bats at the death. There's no scenario where all four are at peak usage.
Permutation 1 — Samson keeps, Dhoni bats at 6/7
Per ESPNcricinfo's IPL 2026 coverage, Fleming has been signalling that Samson retains the gloves even after Dhoni is fit.
The XI: Mhatre, Samson (wk), Ruturaj, Jadeja, Dube, Dhoni, Ravindra, Deepak Chahar, Pathirana, Mustafizur, Noor Ahmad
Pros:
- Samson's form (115* vs DC) is too good to drop
- Dhoni at 6 is the finisher he always was — closer role, not opener-anchor
- Mhatre + Samson = two attackers in the top 3
Cons:
- Dhoni getting only 3-4 overs to bat is controversial among fans
- Ruturaj (captain) batting at 3 not opening is a role demotion
Permutation 2 — Dhoni keeps, Samson drops to No. 4
The XI: Mhatre, Ruturaj, Samson, Jadeja, Dube, Dhoni (wk & c), Ravindra, Chahar, Pathirana, Mustafizur, Noor Ahmad
Pros:
- Dhoni back as captain-keeper — symbolic continuity
- Samson at 4 lets him anchor with pinch-hitters (Dube, Jadeja) around him
Cons:
- Samson keeping has been the tactical success of IPL 2026 for CSK
- Moving Samson from opener to No. 4 is a massive role change mid-season
- Dhoni's keeping workload at 44 is a known risk
Permutation 3 — Samson opens, Dhoni is Impact Player
The XI: Mhatre + Samson at top, Ruturaj at 3, Jadeja at 4, Dube at 5. Dhoni enters as Impact Player at the 13-15th over window as a finisher.
Pros:
- Gets everyone on the field without reshuffling roles
- Dhoni's Impact Player entry is hype fuel — Chepauk would erupt
- Preserves Dhoni's batting for when it matters most
Cons:
- Uses the Impact Player slot entirely on a batter — limits bowling flexibility
- Dhoni at the death is asking a 44-year-old to face unfamiliar bowlers cold
- If CSK bat first and lose early wickets, Dhoni comes in with 12 overs left, not his optimal setup
Permutation 4 — Ruturaj drops out (most controversial)
With Mhatre's strike rate above 160 this season, there's a credible argument that Ruturaj's sub-140 strike rate doesn't fit the top order. Fleming could theoretically rotate Ruturaj out for Sai Sudharsan-style anchor — but that would mean a captain not in the XI, a headache for any franchise.
Probability: Very low. Fleming has historically protected CSK captains. But per The Hindu's IPL commentary, the strike-rate question is "genuinely being debated in the CSK camp."
What Fleming has actually said
Fleming has been careful in press conferences. The signals so far:
- Samson keeping is "working" — unlikely to change
- Dhoni's return "won't mean everyone else shifts"
- The team is building around "finishing power in the last 4 overs"
Reading between the lines: Permutation 1 (Samson keeps, Dhoni bats at 6-7) is the most likely XI when Dhoni returns.
What this means for Dhoni fans
If you came to Chepauk expecting Dhoni to keep and bat up the order the way he did in his prime — you're getting a different version. IPL 2026 Dhoni is a specialist finisher brought on for the final 3-4 overs. He's no longer the engine — he's the closer.
That's not a demotion. It's modern T20 cricket recognising that a 44-year-old with a vintage finishing eye is still the world's best at that one job.
Dream11 take
When Dhoni plays, pick him as a differential. Ownership will be 40-50% — lower than his prime era. His ceiling (20-25 off 8-10 balls) is still a captain's multiplier if CSK need it at the death.
Samson is the banker. Whether keeping or not, his IPL 2026 form makes him a must-pick.
Mhatre is the value pick. Sub-40% ownership in most contests for an opener averaging 160+ SR is a Dream11 inefficiency to exploit.
FAQ
Q: When will MS Dhoni return to the CSK XI? A: Per the CSK medical team's most recent update, Dhoni is expected back within the next 7-10 days — targeting the CSK vs DC fixture on April 27 or a match close to it. No confirmation yet; availability depends on his fitness test.
Q: Will Dhoni keep wickets when he returns? A: Most likely no. Sanju Samson has been keeping throughout IPL 2026 and scored a century (115*) in Match 18. Head coach Stephen Fleming has signalled Samson keeps the gloves, with Dhoni batting as a finisher at No. 6 or 7.
Q: Where will Dhoni bat in the CSK XI? A: Expected at No. 6 or No. 7 — a finisher role for the last 3-4 overs. CSK are unlikely to move him up to No. 4 or No. 5 given Samson's form and his keeping load being taken on.
Q: Will Ruturaj Gaikwad stay as CSK captain? A: Yes. Ruturaj remains captain even with Dhoni's return. Dhoni's public stance has been clear that he wants Ruturaj to continue, though some tactical input from Dhoni during critical overs is likely.
Q: Is Ayush Mhatre's opening spot safe? A: Yes, very likely. His strike rate above 160 this season and his partnership with Samson make him the logical Powerplay anchor. Fleming has been moving Ruturaj out of the opening slot to accommodate Mhatre.
Q: Can Dhoni come in as Impact Player? A: Tactically yes, but unlikely. Using the Impact Player slot entirely on a specialist finisher limits CSK's bowling flexibility. More likely Dhoni is in the starting XI at 6-7 with the Impact Player being a bowler or power-hitter.
Q: What's the biggest risk in this XI? A: Bowling balance. CSK's XI with Dhoni back becomes batting-heavy. With Dube, Jadeja and Ravindra as part-time bowlers, the onus falls on Chahar, Pathirana and Mustafizur. If any one is injured or off-form, CSK's attack is exposed.
Keep reading
IPL 2026 Fantasy Tools
Share this article
Rahul Sharma
Expert in: Ipl 2026Rahul Sharma has played district-level cricket in Mumbai for 8 years and has personally tested more than 50 bats, pads, gloves, and helmets across different price ranges. He joined CricJosh to help Indian club cricketers make smarter equipment choices without overpaying. His reviews are based on real match and net session use, not sponsored samples.
Why trust this review: Rahul has used every product in this review across multiple match and net sessions before writing a word. He buys equipment at retail price and accepts no free samples.
Related Articles